dvd reviews > cinema reviews > DVD reviews > features

Keane - Live - By James Ellaby

Keane proved that they were well and truly over the turmoil of the last couple of years (Tom Chaplin's drug problems and the strained relations between the band during the making of second album Under The Iron Sea) with their arena shows earlier this year, including a storming performance at a rapturous MEN Arena. Recorded on the same tour, Keane Live showcases them at the O2 Arena, which seems to be the new place to get your live DVDs recorded, coming just after one from Scissor Sisters. The setlist is no surprise, packed with hits from Hopes And Fears and most of UTIS, but the amount of noise that Keane make with just keyboards and drums certainly is, as you might not expect them to be able to blast it out at such a large venue, but at times their lack of instrumentation helps the atmosphere because you can hear the crowd singing along much more than you probably could if there were loud guitars drowning them out. Chaplin looks fit and healthy and about half the size he was at his bloated worst before rehab, and spends the entire gig prowling the various areas of a complex stage set to engage with fans on both sides and even down at the back. The pace of the show sags a bit towards the middle when the band shift to a mini-stage for some acoustic tracks, and this works less well on DVD than it seemed to at the gig itself in Manchester, but there's an awesome run of great anthemic songs building up to the climax of Bedshaped. One special part of this gig comes before A Bad Dream, when they get Neil Hannon from The Divine Comedy to read out the WB Yeats poem that inspired it, but frankly his reading isn't great and the large shades he is wearing don't really fit the austere mood that he should be trying to set. It worked much better with a voiceover at the other gigs, but the song itself is fantastic, made all the better by the atmospheric clips of wartime life shown on the screens, and these are well used throughout the show. There's all the usual bonus features too, like alternate angles (oooh), behind the scenes stuff and footage of the soundcheck. It's a great show by a great live band and a perfect way to send off one of the best British albums of the last couple of years...

Nelly Furtado - Loose Live - By James Ellaby

Loose has certainly given Nelly Furtado's career a real shot in the arm just as she was started to drift into the land of the one-hit wonder (admittedly she'd had more than one hit, but her second album never hit the heights commercially). It's been so successful that she is still releasing singles from it over a year and a half after it came out, and this DVD of a live show from Toronto is here too, and who can blame her. Whoa Nelly! sold 4.9 million copies, Folklore sold 1.8m and Loose has already sold well over 6m, so you can't really blame her for wanting to cement that success with this release. She still occupies quite a bizarre place in modern pop music, clearly having more talent than most of her contemporaries could ever hope to possess, and her reinvention as a sexy edgy star after the world-folk-pop of Folklore raised a few eyebrows at first. The closest person to her in terms of style of music is probably Gwen Stefani, but this show pales in comparison with the ones Stefani put on a couple of months ago, which were full of energy, fun and imagination. Loose - Live perhaps reflects Furtado's own slight unease in this new role (after all, for Stefani it was only ever an amusing diversion, whereas this is what Furtado doesn't have a band to fall back on) so it comes across as neither a fully-fledged pop concert nor the kind of gig she put on to tour her last album. The band are more prominently displayed than you'd normally get at this kind of show, but there are also backing dancers for almost all the songs, and yet there doesn't seem to be any real point to them, other than they are there because someone thought they probably should be. A fairly dull stage set doesn't help either and the only real injection of colour comes with Forca (the theme tune to Euro 2004, with inflatable footballs thrown into a slightly bemused Canadian audience) and perhaps that too reflects that Furtado would feel more comfortable playing music like that. This gives the show a slightly lifeless feeling for most of it, only really coming to life on Promiscuous and Maneater towards the end, and it's even more noticeable on DVD, where you are detached from events and don't feel as much a part of it. That makes Loose - Live a rather disappointing live DVD that will still probably appeal to die-hard fans, but has little in it for the rest of us.

Moliere - By Paul Bullock

Quick history lesson. Jean-Baptiste Poquelin, or Moliere (Roman Duris) as he is better known, was a French writer and actor who penned a collection of celebrated plays between his birth in 1622 and death in 1673. However, while much is known of his life and work, there is a grey area in his early biography that remains a mystery to even the most well-read of scholars, and this whimsical French fancy creates a fictional account of what may have happened during that lost period. Moliere, writer/director Laurent Tirard speculates, spent his time playing out a sort of Cyrano de Bergerac story with Monsieur Jourdain (Fabrice Luchini), a rich but foolish nobleman who enlists Moliere's writing skills to help him woo beautiful marquise Célimène (Ludivine Sainger). But the path to true love never runs smooth and while Jourdain is attempting to win over Célimène, Moliere, now undercover as respectable priest Tartuffe, falls for his employer’s neglected wife Elmire (Laura Morante). From that description it’ll be no surprise to learn that Moliere owes a debt of gratitude to the witty romantic entanglements of Shakespeare in Love, with lines and situations taken from Moliere's later works, just as Romeo and Juliet was heavily relied upon and referenced in John Madden's film. The duality of comedy and tragedy constitutes the picture's meaty subtext, making it's a little more heavyweight than the rather slight 1998 Oscar winner. However, this is still very much frothy Sunday evening fare that is unlikely to win over those averse to period films or unaware of Moliere's works. Those who do buy the DVD will find only a short behind the scenes featurette to sate their Moliere appetite, but the lush colours and sterling cinematography of the film itself are beautifully presented on a crisp transfer.

Scissor Sisters - Hurrah, A Year Of Ta-Dah! - By James Ellaby

Music DVDs are ten-a-penny nowadays. All you need to do is release one album with maybe one memorable single on it and you can bring out a DVD. Just ask MIKA. Scissor Sisters have been around a little bit longer than that and are clearly a band who will be around for quite some time as they've got a large fanbase and plenty of potential to keep on making great music for years to come. Hurrah, A Year Of Ta-Dah! is neither a live DVD with a tacked-on documentary nor a docu-DVD with some live stuff on it, it is a DVD with a great documentary and a full live concert from the O2 Arena, which is basically the same show as they put on at the MEN Arena earlier this year. As well as that, you get the videos from the Ta-Dah singles, all of which are certainly worth watching again, a nine-song live CD, double-sided poster and a bonus acoustic mini-gig, which goes a long way to proving that there is a heck of a lot more depth and talent in this band than their camp antics on stage and off it might suggest to some. Documentaries about bands on tour tend to fall into two categories, either exposing them in a way that they might not have intended, or coming across as so sanitised that you learn absolutely nothing and have no fun whatsoever watching them. Hurrah is somewhere in the middle, but in a good way, because the band come across as genuinely warm and engaging people with a great sense of humour and despite the jokey comments from their roadies, their sudden rise to fame doesn't seem to have turned them into egotistical monsters. Spending a year in the life of Scissor Sisters certainly seems like a fun ride through wacky live concerts with an almost endless collection of costumes, as well as frankly surreal TV appearances, not least the European Christmas show where the audience all have blacked-up faces, leading to a real debate within the band as to whether to actually perform or not. All the members of the band are good fun, and while you may grow tired of Jake Shears' Duracell Bunny energy and enthusiasm, it does seem to be genuine rather than an act, and he's infectiously happy throughout. The worst thing you can say about a DVD release from a band is that they don't seem to have taken the time to make it worthwhile, and there's not even a hint of that here, making it an essential purchase for fans and well worth a watch even for more casual members of the sisterhood. Hurrah!

MIKA - Live In Cartoon Motion - By James Ellaby

At the start of the year, MIKA looked set for superstardom. He was camp, had a load of infectiously catchy pop songs in his locker and was tapping into the spirits of Freddie Mercury and Leo Sayer for the nostalgics. His first single Grace Kelly was a massive hit and the world was at his feet, but it all went a little bit sour when he was offered the chance to cement his successes by supporting Take That around Europe. He turned it down saying that he was a little bit too big for that kind of supporting role, suggesting a little bit of an ego, and while the Great British public can be forgiving of that, they do tend to like you to have earned the right to be that full of yourself (Robbie Williams being a good example). MIKA quite clearly hadn't, and while he's still done alright over here since then, he's hardly dominated 2007 in the way that he could and probably should have done. Live In Cartoon Motion is his first DVD (obviously) and shows him playing a gig at L'Olympia in Paris, and whether you enjoy it or not probably depends on how much you want to see Stephen Mangan from Green Wing (and those Barclaycard adverts) doing Leo Sayer on Stars In Their Eyes. Seriously though, MIKA is a decent live performer, and has the French crowd in the palm of his hands throughout, which is an achievement for a show that is heavy on filler material, and where the best song isn't even one of his, with I Want You Back highlighting the deficiencies in most of what he plays from Life In Cartoon Motion. The grand finale of Love Today, Grace Kelly and Lollipop is obviously the highlight, but you have to wonder how many people will bother to watch any of the rest of it or just skip to the end. It really is a bit early for MIKA to be releasing a live DVD, and Live In Cartoon Motion isn't great by any means, but still as a memento for the fans, it's probably worth getting. For sceptics, neither it nor the accompanying documentary will make us like him any more than we already do. Which isn't much.

Girls Aloud - Get Girls Aloud's Style - By James Ellaby

What the hell is this? A music DVD about Girls Aloud where they aren't playing a gig or anything, but are talking about their 'style'? People would want to buy this? To be honest it's got to be a better bet than that thrilling Katie Melua documentary about the time she went to a Norwegian oil rig, but Get Girls Aloud's Style shares with that the suspicion that it's the kind of thing that fans would watch on TV but not actually want to pay for. There's no doubt that they are the biggest deal in pop music at the moment, and with a new album out next week, it's not a bad time to release this, but watching Girls Aloud sit around and bitch about the clothes they had to wear in their early music videos and single covers isn't much fun for anyone, least of all the poor unfortunate stylists and directors who put them in those clothes. Of course, the title suggests that you can 'get' their style and they do offer their tips so that aspiring fans can try and look like them, but given that they spend half the DVD slagging off the way they looked in most of their old outfits, is it worth trying to emulate them now when they'll probably hate it themselves in a few months? I guess that's fashion though isn't it? Of course, whether or not you enjoy this video probably depends on how excited you get about chapter titles like 'Sarah On Accessories' and 'Nadine On Shoes'. The bonus features are basically all the videos from all the singles they've released, with Cheryl Cole and Sarah Harding providing commentaries on them, and you can guess how pointless and inane most of their insights are, but of course that doesn't stop them nattering so much that they even get cut off halfway through sentences when the video stops. All this stuff would probably be great if it was all bonus features to something a bit more meaningful, but on its own, Get Girls Aloud's Style isn't really worth bothering with for anyone other than the most die-hard fans, particularly with an album just around the corner to spend the money on instead.